So, you didn’t get that promotion you worked so hard for. Now what? It’s a tough pill to swallow, but you’ve got options for moving forward.
For years, I’ve seen people deal with this exact situation. The same tried-and-true advice I’ve used myself can help you through it too.
You put in all the effort. You worked extra hours, networked with the right people, and truly believed this promotion was yours. Your boss calls you in, asks you to close the door, and sits you down. They look a little serious, but you figure it’s just the gravity of the moment. Then, they drop the bomb: someone else got the promotion.
Being passed over is a uniquely painful kind of rejection. Big opportunities don’t come around every day, and depending on your situation, this might mean waiting months, even years, for another shot. It’s even worse when you’ve poured so much time, effort, and creativity into making yourself the perfect candidate, only to be told it wasn’t enough.
So, what do you do next? Do you drown your sorrows in what was supposed to be a celebratory drink? Do you lie awake at night trying to convince yourself you never wanted it anyway? Or do you plot an elaborate revenge scheme, perhaps involving sardines in your boss’s AC? (Probably not that last one.)
However you deal with the disappointment – and you definitely need to process it – you’ll eventually have to pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and decide on a plan. The bad news is you didn’t get what you wanted. The good news is you still have choices.
Option 1: Try Again
I know, I know. "Try again?" you might be thinking. "I just wasted weeks, even months, chasing this! And you want me to just ‘try again’?"
That’s not exactly what I mean. This isn’t about blindly repeating the same actions. As the saying goes, doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results is a bit crazy. What you need is a smart plan, and that starts with figuring out where things went wrong.
To be honest, this part might not be what you want to hear either. Replaying the whole process can be tough. Nobody enjoys revisiting their failures, but it’s always better than just trying something new and hoping for the best.
In an ideal world, your manager would give you clear feedback. Maybe not right when they deliver the bad news, but soon after, they should be straightforward. Things like, "You didn’t get it because you lack experience," or "You’re too valuable where you are," or "You started a gerbil-fighting ring in the break room."
But this isn’t an ideal world. You can’t always count on someone explaining why you didn’t make the cut. Delivering bad news is hard, and even experienced managers might feel awkward pointing out your weaknesses to your face. Still, you can’t let their discomfort stop you from finding out what happened. Be prepared to ask them directly, politely but firmly. You might even need to help them out, saying something like, "Look, I know this is uncomfortable for both of us, but I need to understand how I can improve." If you approach them with firm but respectful directness, you’ll likely get the same in return.
Once you have all the facts, you can start making an effective plan.
Go to your supervisor with a solid plan to fix those weak areas. Need more experience? Many managers are happy to delegate tasks (bit by bit) and free up their own time. Want a better understanding of the company? Ask about cross-training; other departments are usually glad to have extra help in the wings.
Whatever your plan looks like, it’s crucial to involve your manager from the beginning. Make it clear that you’re taking concrete steps to address any areas they believe you need to work on. Don’t just take on a bunch of new duties and then surprise them later. That might feel more like an ambush than a fair agreement.
This might seem a bit overwhelming, but remember that it’s much faster, cheaper, and easier for a company to promote someone from within than to spend time and money hiring an outsider. Most employers would rather develop talent from their own teams, but you have to clearly show them that’s what you want.
Unless, of course, it isn’t what you want. There’s a solution for that too.
Option 2: Forget the Promotion – Get What You Really Want
You’ve probably been taught since childhood that promotions are always good. If you’ve grown up in the modern world, you’ve likely been bombarded with the idea that everyone is chasing that elusive promotion, believing it will magically bring respect, confidence, authority, and money.
It’s time to let go of that image.
Forget what society expects. Ask yourself what you truly want. Do you really want to dedicate even more hours to a job that might not align with your passions or beliefs? Is managing a chain of pet costume stores worth an extra twenty hours a week? If it is, great! But don’t feel like you constantly need to outdo others to chase something you never genuinely desired in the first place.
This isn’t an excuse to give up, or a suggestion to move to a cabin in the mountains (though, you do you!). It’s an invitation to think creatively. Take a step back and consider what aspect of the promotion appealed to you most. Was it more flexible hours? The chance to travel? The opportunity to gain experience you could use elsewhere? These are all things you can pursue outside of the traditional promotion path.
This approach is often called "expanding the pie" in negotiations – treating the situation as a win-win rather than one person losing for another to gain. When done well, it can lead to amazing results.
For example, if the main draw of the promotion was the travel it offered, you could go to your boss and say something like:
"I understand I didn’t get the promotion, but I genuinely believe my public speaking skills are the best in the office. I think I’d be great giving updates at corporate, which would allow [the person who got the promotion] to focus on things here. Plus, I know [the person who got the promotion] probably doesn’t want to travel all over the country with their family at home, and I definitely have the flexibility. Given how much I’ve grown here, I think this is a pretty reasonable idea."
In this scenario, everyone benefits. You get to travel, your former rival spends more time with family, and your employer gets a focused manager and makes good use of your talents. Plus, your boss might feel a bit obligated to give you something after turning you down for the promotion.
Will this always work? Honestly, no, not always. Even the most creative suggestions can fall flat, and sometimes even the most supportive bosses are tied down by rules.
But while every company has its regulations, you’d be surprised how much flexibility you can find when you really push. Maybe you won’t take over all of your competitor’s travel duties, but you might get to join them on some key trips. That’s a foot in the door, and it’s certainly more than you’d get if you approached the promotion with an all-or-nothing mindset.
You can’t always get everything you want, but you can still carve out a pretty good piece for yourself.
But what if that’s still not enough? Then it might be time to…
Option 3: Pack Up – Move On
As hard as it might be, this is something you have to consider.
The harsh truth is that office politics can play as big a role in who gets ahead as performance reviews do. Sure, maybe you lost out to someone more qualified. But it’s also possible you’re not getting a fair chance, or you’re seen as a threat to the current way of doing things, or you simply remind your boss of a mysterious crime-solver who dated their college sweetheart decades ago.
There’s a time and place to be stoic, but this isn’t it.
Let’s be clear: you don’t owe your employer anything. Ignore anyone who tells you otherwise. The economic ups and downs our generation has lived through over the past 20 years prove that.
You’re the one investing your intelligence, your drive, and the majority of your waking hours, year after year, into a company’s success. If that company doesn’t appreciate it – if it can’t fairly compensate you for it – then there’s absolutely no reason for you to stay there. Life’s too short.
This sounds simple, but for Millennials, it can be particularly tough to cut ties. Many of us came of age during the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. It was hard enough to land our first jobs, and despite our reputation as job-hoppers, many of us actually long for the stability of a long-term role, especially as we approach our forties. We’re still battling unfair stereotypes about being lazy and entitled. Don’t let your boss, coworkers, or (most importantly) yourself guilt you into staying somewhere where your growth isn’t valued, just to disprove a stereotype.
You don’t need to be the person who dedicates forty years of their life to a company that drains them and then discards them the moment they can be replaced. You shouldn’t feel guilty for looking out for your own best interests. What you need to be is smarter.
This is where your exit strategy comes in. Everyone’s plan will be different, but they should all follow these three core principles:
-
Don’t Burn Bridges. As justified as your anger might be, don’t storm into your manager’s office, throw down a resignation letter, and call everyone names. Nothing in life is ever certain, and having a good relationship with past employers can be a valuable fallback. Also, time your departure carefully. Giving two weeks’ notice is standard etiquette, and you should avoid leaving your boss in a bind, especially since they might be contacted for references later.
-
Hang On Until You Can’t. Unless your current job is truly unbearable, it’s best to stick with it until you have another one lined up. Even a low-paying job is better than no job, and ideally, you’ll have enough savings to get by if things don’t work out perfectly. This means you need to commit to making a plan for finding something new.
-
Resign In Person. Whenever possible, deliver your resignation yourself. Your directness will be appreciated, and it puts you in a position to answer questions or discuss counter-offers. Be direct but not rude. And whatever you do, try to frame the bad news between two genuine compliments. Something like: "I want to let you know how much I’ve valued the opportunity to grow here over the past couple of years, but I think it’s time for me to move on… [insert your brief, clear reason here] …I want to say again how grateful I am for everything I’ve learned and for the chances I’ve been given. Thank you again." A gentle but firm explanation can soften the blow. Even the toughest bosses can have their feelings hurt when someone leaves. If you work remotely, a face-to-face video call is appropriate, and it’s good to have a resignation letter prepared to make it official and help you clearly express your thoughts.
Offer an Ultimatum (Carefully)
While it’s unlikely your boss will break down in tears begging you to stay, it’s smart to go into their office with an offer in mind. This is, after all, the real reason you’re explaining why you’re considering leaving – not to criticize your employer, but to give them one last chance to fix things. Even if things can’t be mended, it at least gives them a chance to feel involved in your decision.
Again, ask yourself: what are the absolute essentials you’re looking for? What would they need to offer to make your current position (without the promotion) worth staying for? Understand that this isn’t a negotiation; it needs to be your absolute bare minimum. If they can’t meet it, then there’s nothing else to do. It’s that simple.
You can’t always climb the ladder, but you can always move forward.